21 Old-School Collectibles You’ll Wish You Kept

Fashion & Trends
By Jasmine Hughes

Nostalgia has a way of adding value to the things we cherished in the past. Many of us have fond memories of toys and collectibles that were once the center of our world.

Whether it was a toy we longed for, a card we traded with friends, or a quirky item that brought joy, these collectibles from the past can now bring more than just sentimental value. Here’s a dive into 21 old-school collectibles that you might wish you had kept.

1. Pokémon Cards

© Sotheby’s

Flipping through a deck of Pokémon cards, each card held the allure of secrets and power. The shiny Charizard was the crown jewel, the card everyone wanted. Who knew these cards would become such valuable treasures?

Today, the market for these cards has surged, with some fetching prices that could rival a down payment on a house. The detailed artwork, strategic gameplay, and the nostalgia of trading with friends at recess make Pokémon cards a timeless collectible.

Their value has grown as collectors and enthusiasts from the original era seek to reclaim a piece of their childhood.

2. Pogs and Slammers

© Etsy

Pogs were the epitome of ’90s playground currency. These small, circular cardboard pieces, adorned with vivid designs, were used in a game that combined skill and chance.

The Slammers, heavier and often metallic, added an element of strategy. Every kid dreamed of having the coolest Slammers to enhance their stack.

While the fad was fleeting, the nostalgia lingers, and some unique designs are now hard to find. Pogs remind us of simpler times, when a small piece of cardboard could bring immense joy and the thrill of competition.

3. Vintage Lunchboxes

© eBay

Back in the day, a lunchbox was more than just a vessel for your midday meal. It was a statement, a piece of identity showcasing beloved cartoon characters or superheroes.

The metallic clang of opening one, revealing sandwiches and snacks, evokes memories of school days past. These lunchboxes have become collector’s items, especially those featuring classic characters in pristine condition.

While some show signs of wear and tear from years of use, their charm remains, offering a nostalgic peek into a simpler era where lunchtime was a personal parade of pop culture.

4. PEZ Dispensers

© eBay

PEZ dispensers, with their quirky heads and satisfying mechanical action, turned candy consumption into an event. Collectors scoured candy stores to find dispensers featuring their favorite characters, from superheroes to cartoon icons.

The thrill was in the hunt for rare editions, each dispenser a tiny piece of pop culture history.

Even today, PEZ enthusiasts trade and auction these colorful plastic marvels. Some rare editions fetch surprising sums, proving that even a simple candy dispenser can transcend its original purpose and become a cherished collectible.

5. Cassette Tapes

© The Hungry JPEG

Before digital playlists, mixtapes were the language of emotion. Creating one was an art, capturing the essence of feelings in a series of tracks meticulously recorded onto cassette tapes. The tactile satisfaction of pressing play and hearing the whirring noise as the tape spun was a sensory delight.

Today, these tapes are more than just relics; they’re sought after by retro music enthusiasts who cherish the analog sound. Cassette tapes encapsulate the nostalgia of a time when music sharing was a personal and heartfelt gesture, not just a click away.

6. Beanie Babies

© The Krazy Coupon Lady

In the ’90s, Beanie Babies were more than just toys; they were an investment. Everyone seemed to be collecting these plush creatures, hoping they’d be worth a fortune someday.

Their soft, tactile appeal made them cuddle-worthy, while the promise of rarity drove collectors wild. Remember that little heart-shaped tag?

Keeping it intact was crucial. Today, some of these critters are indeed worth a mint, especially those rare editions that were retired early. It’s a reminder of how a simple stuffed toy revolutionized collecting and even sparked a buying frenzy.

7. Polly Pocket Sets

© Etsy

Polly Pockets were like tiny treasure chests. Opening these compact cases revealed minuscule worlds that sparked imagination. Each set was a delightful surprise, a diorama filled with tiny figures and accessories.

These pocket-sized playsets were perfect for on-the-go entertainment, easily fitting into a child’s pocket. Today, collectors seek these miniature marvels, especially the vintage editions with intricate designs.

Polly Pocket sets have become nostalgic collectibles that harken back to a time of simpler, imaginative play when the only limit was the size of your pocket.

8. Original Star Wars Toys

© eBay

The force was strong with these toys. Original Star Wars action figures were more than just toys; they were gateways to a galaxy far, far away. Kids reimagined epic battles, creating their adventures with these figures.

Today, these action figures, especially those still in their packaging, are highly coveted by collectors.

The nostalgic allure of these toys is tied to the legendary saga that continues to inspire new generations. Owning a piece of the original Star Wars memorabilia is like holding a piece of cinematic history.

9. Tamagotchis

© ToyWiz.com

Tamagotchis were the digital pets that demanded your attention and care, living in a tiny screen you carried everywhere. A beep from your pocket meant it was time to feed or play with your pet.

Shaped like an egg, each Tamagotchi was a personal companion, though many ended up forgotten, with their beeping pleas unheard. Today, these gadgets are cherished by collectors who remember them fondly.

Tamagotchis are a nostalgic symbol of an era where technology began to merge with daily life in playful ways, capturing hearts and time alike.

10. Game Boy Consoles and Cartridges

© Amazon.com

Game Boy was the portal to countless hours of pixelated adventure. This handheld console, with its greenish screen and iconic design, was a staple for kids in the ’90s. From battling through Pokémon lands to dodging obstacles in Mario’s world, these games defined a generation of gamers.

Today, the original Game Boy and its cartridges are prized for their nostalgic charm and simplicity. They represent a golden era of gaming, before the complexity of today’s consoles, where gameplay and imagination took center stage.

11. Comic Books

© Quality Comix

Comic books opened the gates to fantastical worlds where superheroes soared and villains plotted. Each issue was a portal to epic adventures, with the turn of every page filled with suspense and vibrant artistry.

First editions became prized possessions, especially those featuring the debut of iconic characters. As pop culture staples, comic books continue to captivate new audiences, their value only increasing with time.

For collectors, these illustrated stories offer more than just entertainment; they’re historical artifacts that celebrate creativity and imagination in full color.

12. Happy Meal Toys

© Reddit

Happy Meal toys turned fast food into a cherished childhood experience. Each meal was an adventure, with the anticipation of discovering which toy awaited inside. From transforming robots to beloved cartoon characters, these toys were an integral part of growing up.

Today, collectors seek early editions, particularly those in pristine condition. Happy Meal toys capture the essence of youthful excitement and the simple joy of a surprise. They remind us of a time when a trip to the drive-thru meant more than just a meal; it was a memory in the making.

13. Hot Wheels Cars

© CNN

Hot Wheels cars brought the thrill of the raceway into living rooms. These miniature cars, with their sleek designs and vibrant colors, ignited imaginations and fueled competitive races on makeshift tracks.

Collectors cherish rare editions, each car a testament to intricate craftsmanship and creativity. Hot Wheels remain a beloved collectible, symbolizing speed and adventure on a small scale.

For many, they are a reminder of childhood races and the excitement of watching their favorite car zoom down the track, a blur of color and nostalgia.

14. Barbie Dolls

© Amazon.com

Barbie dolls were icons of fashion and imagination. Each doll, with her array of outfits and accessories, provided endless storytelling possibilities. Collectors prize early editions and special releases, which capture the evolution of style and cultural trends.

Barbie has been a pilot, an astronaut, and everything in between, inspiring generations to dream big.

The nostalgia of owning a vintage Barbie is enhanced by the memories of countless hours spent dressing and posing this beloved doll, making her an enduring symbol of creativity and empowerment.

15. My Little Pony Figures

© Schylling

My Little Pony figures brought magical adventures to life with their colorful designs and enchanting backstories. Each pony, with its distinctive cutie mark, sparked creativity and joy. The soft, brushable manes and tails made them irresistible to young collectors.

Today, these figures are collectibles sought after for their nostalgic charm. Owning a vintage My Little Pony is like holding a piece of the whimsical worlds they inhabit, a reminder of the imaginative play that transcended the ordinary and welcomed the fantastical.

16. Vintage Board Games

© Roll to Review

Vintage board games were the cornerstone of family gatherings and sleepovers. Games like Mouse Trap and Fireball Island, with their elaborate setups and engaging gameplay, brought people together for hours of fun.

These games are now collector’s items, cherished for their nostalgic value and intricate designs. Each game is a portal to evenings filled with laughter and friendly competition.

Collecting vintage board games is like preserving a piece of social history, where analog fun reigned supreme, and screens were far from the center of entertainment.

17. Baseball Cards

© Moneywise

Baseball cards were more than just collectibles; they were gateways into the world of America’s favorite pastime. Each card, featuring player stats and vibrant images, was a treasure trove of information and excitement.

Collectors yearned for cards of legendary players, knowing they held a piece of sports history in their hands.

Today, vintage baseball cards are still prized, their value increasing as time passes and the legends they depict become immortalized in sports lore. They capture the essence of the sport and the nostalgia of collecting.

18. Cabbage Patch Kids

© eBay

Cabbage Patch Kids were more than dolls; they were companions with their own unique identities. Each came with an adoption certificate, making the experience personal and endearing.

The soft bodies and unique faces of these dolls made them instantly recognizable. Today, collectors seek the original versions, which bring back memories of a childhood fad that took the world by storm.

Cabbage Patch Kids remain a cherished collectible, symbolizing the joy of adoption and the magic of owning a one-of-a-kind friend in the form of a doll.

19. Lisa Frank Stationery

© eBay

Lisa Frank stationery was an explosion of color, transforming ordinary school supplies into magical artifacts. Each piece, adorned with rainbows, unicorns, and other fantastical creatures, was a personal style statement.

Collectors now seek out these vibrant items for their nostalgic appeal. Lisa Frank’s designs were more than just stationery; they were a celebration of creativity and individuality.

For many, these bright and cheery items are a reminder of school days filled with color and imagination, where expressing one’s personality was as easy as opening a notebook.

20. Yo-Yos (Like Duncan Butterfly)

© YoYoSam

Yo-yos like the Duncan Butterfly were simple yet captivating toys that spun their way into our hearts. Mastering tricks required patience and skill, and each successful ‘walk the dog’ or ‘around the world’ was a triumph.

Collectors prize these iconic yo-yos, especially rare designs that are now hard to find.

The nostalgia of a yo-yo lies in its simplicity and the joy of mastering a skill. It’s a reminder of a time when entertainment was hands-on, and a small, spinning toy could provide endless hours of fun and challenge.

21. Old Video Game Systems

© Retro Gaming of Denver

Old video game systems like the NES, Sega Genesis, and Atari were gateways to virtual worlds that defined a generation of gamers. The pixelated graphics and simple controls offered a charm that remains unmatched.

For many, these consoles are treasured collectibles, representing a golden era of gaming innovation.

The nostalgia associated with these systems is profound, as they evoke memories of first gaming experiences and the joy of discovery in pixelated landscapes. Collecting these consoles is a way to preserve the history of gaming and relive those first adventures.