Back in Time Today
The Western genre has produced some of the most iconic films in cinema history. However, not every attempt to capture the rugged spirit of the Wild West has been a success.
Some movies have missed the mark so completely that critics and audiences alike wish they had never been made. This list delves into 30 Western films that have attracted significant criticism for their various failings, be it in storytelling, acting, or overall execution.
While some of these films might offer unintentional entertainment, they mostly serve as a reminder of how challenging it can be to hit the target in Hollywood’s Wild West.
1. Texas Rangers (2001)
In 2001, Texas Rangers attempted to capture the outlaw-chasing excitement of the Old West. Despite its promising premise, the movie fell flat due to a lack of compelling storytelling and character development.
Critics noted the film’s predictable plot and uninspired performances, which failed to bring the historical drama to life. The narrative felt rushed, and the young cast seemed out of place in the gritty setting of the Western frontier.
2. Bandidas (2006)
Bandidas is a 2006 Western action comedy featuring Salma Hayek and Penélope Cruz as bank-robbing heroines. Despite the charismatic lead duo, the movie failed to deliver the laughs or thrills it promised.
The film’s uninspired plot and reliance on stereotypes were met with criticism. While the chemistry between the stars was a highlight, it wasn’t enough to overcome the predictable and formulaic script that left audiences wanting more.
3. Wild Wild West (1999)
Released in 1999, Wild Wild West attempted to blend the charm of the Western genre with futuristic steampunk flair. Unfortunately, the fusion didn’t hit the mark. Critics panned the film for its inconsistent tone and lackluster script.
Starring Will Smith and Kevin Kline, the movie featured a giant mechanical spider, which became emblematic of its over-the-top approach. While it had potential as a fun blockbuster, many felt it lost its way amid the flashy special effects and convoluted plot.
4. Heaven’s Gate (1980)
Once a promising project, Heaven’s Gate became infamous for its role in nearly bankrupting United Artists. Released in 1980, the film was director Michael Cimino’s ambitious attempt to tell an epic story of class struggle in the American West.
However, its excessive length and muddled narrative alienated audiences. The film’s lavish production could not compensate for the lack of focus, and critics were unforgiving of its indulgent approach to storytelling.
5. Jonah Hex (2010)
Jonah Hex hit theaters in 2010 and quickly became a cautionary tale for adaptations of comic books. The film starred Josh Brolin as the titular character, a scarred bounty hunter with a dark past. Despite the intriguing premise, the execution left much to be desired.
The movie’s fragmented storyline and underdeveloped characters failed to engage audiences. Critics pointed out the lack of cohesion and depth, making it hard for viewers to connect with the narrative or its characters.
6. The Ridiculous 6 (2015)
The Ridiculous 6, released in 2015, aimed to parody the Western genre but ended up receiving scathing reviews. The film, starring Adam Sandler and a host of comedians, failed to strike the right comedic tone.
Critics found the humor to be lazy and offensive, missing the mark on clever satire. The over-reliance on tired jokes and stereotypes made it hard for audiences to find the intended humor amid the chaos.
7. The Lone Ranger (2013)
The return of The Lone Ranger in 2013 was met with high expectations, thanks to its star-studded cast including Johnny Depp as Tonto. However, the film struggled to balance humor and action, resulting in a disjointed experience.
With an inflated budget, the movie’s financial performance was disappointing. Critics were not impressed by its uneven pacing and reliance on clichés, which overshadowed the potentially engaging storyline of justice and adventure.
8. American Outlaws (2001)
American Outlaws tried to bring the story of Jesse James and his gang to the big screen with a youthful twist. Released in 2001, the film was criticized for its glossy portrayal of the infamous outlaws.
The lack of historical accuracy and depth in storytelling left critics unimpressed. While the action sequences provided some excitement, the overall film felt superficial, failing to capture the gritty essence of the legendary figures it depicted.
9. Jane Got a Gun (2015)
Despite a star-studded cast, Jane Got a Gun struggled to make an impact in 2015. The film, starring Natalie Portman, faced numerous production challenges that affected its final version.
Critics highlighted the lack of narrative cohesion and emotional depth, which hindered its ability to engage audiences. The film’s potential was overshadowed by its behind-the-scenes turmoil, resulting in a disjointed Western lacking the gravitas it aimed for.
10. Dead Man’s Burden (2012)
Dead Man’s Burden is a 2012 indie Western that promised a gritty and introspective take on frontier life. However, it struggled to resonate with critics and audiences alike.
The film’s slow pacing and sparse dialogue left viewers disengaged, missing the emotional connection necessary for a compelling narrative. Despite its atmospheric setting, the lack of character development and tension made it a forgettable entry in the genre.
11. Bad Girls (1994)
Bad Girls, released in 1994, attempted to offer a fresh perspective by focusing on female bandits. Unfortunately, the film’s execution fell short of its ambition.
Critics were disappointed by its shallow plot and underwhelming performances, which failed to elevate the story of rebellious women in the Wild West. Despite the potential for a groundbreaking narrative, the film was bogged down by clichés and a lack of depth.
12. Shanghai Noon (2000)
Shanghai Noon, a 2000 Western comedy, paired Jackie Chan and Owen Wilson in an East-meets-West adventure. While some enjoyed the film’s humor, others criticized its uneven tone.
The fusion of martial arts and Western tropes led to mixed reviews, with some feeling the film struggled to balance action and comedy. Despite its flaws, the unique pairing of Chan and Wilson brought a fresh dynamic to the genre.
13. The Legend of the Lone Ranger (1981)
1981’s The Legend of the Lone Ranger attempted to revive the iconic character for a new generation. However, the film’s poor execution left it trailing behind its predecessors.
Critics pointed out the lack of charisma and chemistry between the leads, which failed to capture the spirit of the classic Lone Ranger stories. The uninspired action sequences and predictable plot further contributed to its downfall.
14. Posse (1993)
Posse, released in 1993, aimed to showcase a different side of the Western genre by focusing on an African-American cowboy troop. Unfortunately, the film struggled to deliver its intended impact.
The ambitious narrative was hindered by a lack of cohesive storytelling and character depth. Critics noted that, while the film’s concept was promising, it ultimately failed to resonate with audiences due to its uneven execution.
15. South of Heaven, West of Hell (2000)
2000’s South of Heaven, West of Hell attempted to offer a darker, more introspective take on the Western genre. Despite its ambitious vision, the film failed to connect with critics and moviegoers.
The convoluted plot and sluggish pacing were major drawbacks, as they obscured the film’s thematic intentions. Audiences found it difficult to engage with the story, which lacked the clarity and focus needed for a compelling Western.
16. A Million Ways to Die in the West (2014)
A Million Ways to Die in the West sought to bring laugh-out-loud humor to the Western frontier. Released in 2014, the film, directed by and starring Seth MacFarlane, did deliver some comedy but faltered in consistency.
Critics were unimpressed with the uneven humor and lack of a strong narrative arc. While some gags hit the mark, many felt forced, leaving the audience with a taste for a more cohesive comedic approach.
17. Gallowwalkers (2012)
Gallowwalkers is a 2012 Western horror film starring Wesley Snipes. Despite its intriguing mix of genres, the movie was criticized for its incoherent plot and lackluster execution.
The film’s attempt to blend supernatural elements with Western themes resulted in a muddled narrative that struggled to maintain viewer interest. Critics noted that, while the concept had potential, the unpolished final product left much to be desired.
18. The Warrior’s Way (2010)
2010’s The Warrior’s Way brought a unique fusion of martial arts and Western storytelling. Despite its visually striking style, the film couldn’t garner critical acclaim.
The lack of character development and an engaging plot left audiences wanting more substance. Critics found the film’s reliance on visual spectacle insufficient to compensate for its narrative shortcomings, resulting in a missed opportunity to elevate the genre.
19. Big Money Rustlas (2010)
Big Money Rustlas is a 2010 Western comedy featuring the Insane Clown Posse. The film aimed to entertain fans with its outrageous humor but received a lukewarm reception.
Critics found the film’s humor to be juvenile and lacking cleverness. The over-the-top antics and lack of a coherent plot made it difficult for the film to appeal to a broader audience, despite its niche fanbase.
20. Love’s Abiding Joy (2006)
Love’s Abiding Joy is a 2006 faith-based Western drama that struggled to resonate with secular audiences. The film’s earnest approach was met with mixed reviews.
Critics noted the predictable storyline and lack of compelling conflict, which led to a less engaging viewing experience. While the film’s wholesome themes were appreciated by some, its limited appeal kept it from achieving broader acclaim.
21. The Outsider (2019)
2019’s The Outsider was hoped to be a gripping drama set in the West, but fell short due to its lack of originality. The film’s derivative plot and predictable character arcs were points of contention for critics.
Despite the potential for an engaging narrative, the film’s execution felt bland, failing to introduce fresh perspectives to the well-trodden Western genre. As a result, it languished in mediocrity, unable to make a lasting impression.
22. Traded (2016)
Traded, released in 2016, attempted to offer a revenge-driven storyline in the Western frontier. Unfortunately, the film’s lack of depth and originality were significant drawbacks.
Critics noted that the predictable plot and uninspired performances kept it from rising above genre clichés. While the film tried to deliver a tale of redemption, it ultimately failed to resonate with audiences, leaving it lost in the shuffle of similar narratives.
23. Outlaws and Angels (2016)
2016’s Outlaws and Angels aimed to explore the moral complexities of the Western genre but struggled to find its footing. The film’s bleak tone and graphic violence drew criticism for overshadowing its narrative.
While it aspired to present a gritty depiction of frontier justice, the lack of character depth and coherent storytelling hindered its impact. Audiences found it difficult to invest in the film’s dark themes, resulting in a lukewarm reception.
24. 6 Guns (2010)
6 Guns, released in 2010, offered a familiar revenge tale set in the Wild West. Unfortunately, the film’s clichéd plot and lackluster performances failed to impress critics.
The predictable storyline and uninspired dialogue made it difficult for the film to stand out in the crowded Western genre. While the theme of vengeance is a classic trope, the film’s execution left much to be desired, resulting in a forgettable cinematic experience.
25. The Last Rites of Ransom Pride (2010)
2010’s The Last Rites of Ransom Pride promised a gritty, action-packed tale but struggled to deliver a memorable experience. The film’s convoluted plot and inconsistent pacing were major drawbacks.
Critics noted the lack of character development and engaging storytelling, which hindered its ability to captivate audiences. Despite its attempt to offer a unique perspective on the Western genre, the film fell short of achieving its ambitious goals.
26. Dust (2001)
Dust, released in 2001, attempted to tell an unconventional story by blending different time periods and locations. However, the film’s confusing structure and lack of focus left audiences bewildered.
Critics struggled to connect with the disjointed narrative and underdeveloped characters. While the film’s ambitious approach was commendable, it ultimately failed to deliver a coherent and engaging story that audiences could latch onto.
27. The Timber (2015)
The Timber is a 2015 Western thriller set in the unforgiving wilderness. Despite its atmospheric setting, the film struggled to find an audience due to its lack of narrative coherence.
The slow pacing and underdeveloped characters left critics unimpressed. While the film’s visual style captured the harsh beauty of the frontier, it fell short in delivering a compelling story that could sustain viewers’ interest.
28. Into the Badlands (1991)
Into the Badlands is a 1991 Western TV movie that attempted to weave supernatural elements into its narrative. Unfortunately, the film’s execution left much to be desired.
The lack of engaging storytelling and character development hindered its ability to captivate audiences. Despite its intriguing premise, the film’s sluggish pacing and lack of focus contributed to its forgettable status within the genre.
29. Big Muddy (2014)
Big Muddy, released in 2014, aimed to provide a noir-ish take on the Western genre. However, the film’s muddled narrative and lack of compelling characters left critics disappointed.
While the atmospheric setting offered potential, the story failed to deliver the suspense and intrigue necessary for a captivating noir. The disjointed plot and lack of emotional depth limited its impact, resulting in a film that struggled to leave a lasting impression.
30. The Gunfighter (2014)
The Gunfighter, a 2014 short film, sought to blend humor with traditional Western themes. While it garnered some praise for its comedic elements, the film received mixed reviews overall.
The tone’s inconsistency was a point of contention, as it struggled to balance satire and sincerity. Despite its brief runtime, the film faced challenges in maintaining a cohesive narrative, leaving audiences with an uneven experience.