20 Throwback Jams You Won’t Believe You Forgot

Pop Culture
By Ella Brown

Explore a selection of hidden musical gems that, although not widely recognized today, still hold a special place in the hearts of those who remember them. From catchy pop tunes to reflective rock anthems, these forgotten hits continue to resonate with their unique melodies and memorable lyrics. Join us as we revisit twenty tracks that deserve a spot in your playlist.

1. “Steal My Sunshine” – Len

© YouTube

“Steal My Sunshine” by Len captures the essence of summer with its infectious beat and laid-back vibe. Released in 1999, this track is a quintessential feel-good anthem. Its catchy chorus and playful lyrics are sure to transport you back to sunlit days and carefree moments. The song’s unique blend of pop and hip-hop elements gives it a timeless appeal. Whether you’re cruising down the highway or relaxing by the pool, “Steal My Sunshine” is the perfect soundtrack. This tune reminds us that sometimes, it’s the unexpected hits that leave the most lasting impressions.

2. “You Get What You Give” – New Radicals

© IMDb

The New Radicals’ “You Get What You Give” is a spirited anthem of positivity and rebellion. Released in 1998, this track became synonymous with youthful defiance and optimism. Its energetic melody and thought-provoking lyrics encourage listeners to challenge societal norms and embrace authenticity. The song is a reminder that genuine connections and self-expression are invaluable. With its catchy hooks and anthemic chorus, “You Get What You Give” continues to inspire a sense of hope and empowerment. It’s a track that speaks to the dreamers and doers of every generation.

3. “Flagpole Sitta” – Harvey Danger

© IMDb

Harvey Danger’s “Flagpole Sitta” is a sharp, witty critique of modern society. Released in 1997, its catchy punk-infused melody and clever lyrics resonate with those disillusioned by the status quo. The song’s infectious energy and satirical tone make it a standout hit of its time. With lines that capture the angst and irony of youth, it’s a track that still feels relevant today. “Flagpole Sitta” is a reminder that music can be both entertaining and thought-provoking, offering a voice to the restless and the rebellious.

4. “How Bizarre” – OMC

© ABC News

OMC’s “How Bizarre” is a delightful oddity in the world of 90s music. Released in 1995, its unique blend of pop and world music elements creates a sound that’s both catchy and unconventional. The song’s whimsical lyrics and playful rhythm tell an intriguing story of unexpected adventures. Despite its quirky nature, “How Bizarre” became an international sensation, capturing the imagination of listeners worldwide. It’s a reminder that sometimes the most unconventional tracks leave the most lasting impressions. This hit continues to charm with its infectious energy and offbeat storytelling.

5. “She’s So High” – Tal Bachman

© IMDb

Tal Bachman’s “She’s So High” is an ode to unattainable beauty and admiration. Released in 1999, this pop-rock gem features a soaring melody and heartfelt lyrics. Its chorus, both powerful and tender, conveys the awe and wonder of infatuation. The song’s romantic charm lies in its ability to evoke feelings of longing and admiration. “She’s So High” remains a beloved track for those who have ever found themselves captivated by someone out of reach. Its timeless appeal and emotional depth make it a standout hit from the late 90s music scene.

6. “Barely Breathing” – Duncan Sheik

© IMDb

Duncan Sheik’s “Barely Breathing” is a heartfelt ballad exploring themes of heartbreak and resilience. Released in 1996, its introspective lyrics and evocative melody capture the emotional turmoil of lost love. The song’s gentle rhythm and soothing vocals offer solace to those navigating the complexities of relationships. “Barely Breathing” resonates with listeners who have experienced the pain of unrequited love and the strength to move forward. Its emotional depth and soulful delivery make it a timeless classic that continues to touch hearts. This track is a beautiful reminder of the healing power of music.

7. “Breakfast at Tiffany’s” – Deep Blue Something

© American Songwriter

Deep Blue Something’s “Breakfast at Tiffany’s” is a charming ode to classic romance and connection. Released in 1995, its upbeat melody and catchy chorus celebrate shared memories and common ground. The song’s lyrics tell the story of a couple finding solace in their mutual appreciation for the Audrey Hepburn film. Its blend of pop-rock elements and feel-good vibes makes it an enduring favorite. “Breakfast at Tiffany’s” reminds us that sometimes the simplest shared moments can strengthen relationships. This hit continues to capture the hearts of those seeking connection through nostalgia and shared experiences.

8. “Closing Time” – Semisonic

© Rock Cellar Magazine

Semisonic’s “Closing Time” is more than just a bar closing anthem. Released in 1998, it reflects on transitions and new beginnings with a melodic blend of rock and introspection. Its lyrics, often misinterpreted, convey a deeper message about life’s inevitable changes. The song’s memorable chorus and soothing melody have made it a staple for farewells and endings. “Closing Time” reminds us that with every ending comes a new opportunity. It’s a universally relatable track that continues to resonate with listeners seeking closure or embarking on new journeys.

9. “I Try” – Macy Gray

© Louder Than War

Macy Gray’s “I Try” is a soulful exploration of love and vulnerability. Released in 1999, its distinctive voice and poignant lyrics convey the complexities of romantic relationships. The song’s blend of soul, pop, and jazz elements creates a rich and emotive sound. Gray’s powerful vocals and heartfelt delivery express the struggles and triumphs of love. “I Try” resonates with anyone who has experienced the bittersweet nature of relationships. Its emotional depth and unique sound have cemented its status as a standout track in the late 90s music scene. This song continues to move listeners with its raw honesty.

10. “Crush” – Jennifer Paige

© YouTube

Jennifer Paige’s “Crush” is a playful pop hit that explores the excitement of infatuation. Released in 1998, its bubbly melody and catchy lyrics capture the exhilaration of newfound attraction. The song’s upbeat tempo and infectious chorus make it a dancefloor favorite. “Crush” is a reminder of the joy and spontaneity that come with a new romantic interest. Its playful nature and relatable theme have made it a beloved track for those experiencing the thrills of a budding crush. This hit continues to bring smiles and energy to listeners, celebrating the lighter side of love.

11. “Save Tonight” – Eagle-Eye Cherry

© GQ

Eagle-Eye Cherry’s “Save Tonight” is a heartfelt ode to cherishing the present moment. Released in 1997, its acoustic melody and reflective lyrics encourage listeners to savor time with loved ones. The song’s soothing rhythm and nostalgic vibe create a sense of warmth and comfort. “Save Tonight” is a reminder of the fleeting nature of time and the importance of making memories. Its universal message and emotional resonance have made it a timeless favorite. This track continues to inspire listeners to embrace the beauty of now, offering a musical embrace to those who seek connection and closeness.

12. “Tubthumping” – Chumbawamba

© 9Now – Nine

Chumbawamba’s “Tubthumping” is an anthem of resilience and celebration. Released in 1997, its infectious chorus and upbeat rhythm invite listeners to embrace life’s ups and downs. The song’s blend of rock, pop, and punk elements creates a sound that’s both energetic and unifying. “Tubthumping” is a reminder that setbacks are temporary, and the spirit of perseverance prevails. Its catchy hooks and resilience-themed lyrics have made it a staple at celebrations and gatherings. This track continues to resonate with those who believe in the power of bouncing back and finding joy in the face of challenges.

13. “Inside Out” – Eve 6

© The Daily Dot

Eve 6’s “Inside Out” is a dynamic rock anthem exploring themes of identity and emotional complexity. Released in 1998, its energetic guitar riffs and introspective lyrics capture the struggles of youth. The song’s raw honesty and infectious rhythm make it a compelling listen. “Inside Out” speaks to those navigating the challenges of self-discovery and personal growth. Its blend of intensity and introspection has made it a favorite among fans of rock music. This track continues to resonate with listeners who appreciate its candid exploration of life’s complexities and the search for authenticity.

14. “Standing Outside a Broken Phone Booth” – Primitive Radio Gods

© YouTube

Primitive Radio Gods’ “Standing Outside a Broken Phone Booth” is a haunting exploration of isolation and reflection. Released in 1996, its atmospheric soundscape and introspective lyrics delve into themes of loneliness and longing. The song’s unique blend of rock, electronic, and blues elements creates a moody and evocative experience. “Standing Outside a Broken Phone Booth” resonates with those who have felt disconnected and introspective. Its haunting melody and poignant storytelling continue to captivate listeners seeking a deeper connection. This track is a reminder of the power of music to evoke complex emotions and thoughts.

15. “Sunny Came Home” – Shawn Colvin

© shawn_colvin

Shawn Colvin’s “Sunny Came Home” is a captivating narrative of renewal and empowerment. Released in 1996, its folk-inspired melody and evocative lyrics tell the story of a woman’s journey to reclaim her life. The song’s blend of acoustic elements and storytelling creates a rich and immersive experience. “Sunny Came Home” speaks to those who have found strength in starting anew. Its compelling narrative and emotional depth have made it a timeless favorite. This track continues to inspire listeners to embrace change and rediscover their own power and resilience.

16. “Counting Blue Cars” – Dishwalla

© Amazon.com

Dishwalla’s “Counting Blue Cars” is a thought-provoking exploration of curiosity and spirituality. Released in 1995, its melodic rock sound and introspective lyrics invite listeners to ponder life’s big questions. The song’s blend of philosophical musings and catchy hooks creates a memorable experience. “Counting Blue Cars” resonates with those who seek answers and understanding in a complex world. Its introspective nature and engaging storytelling continue to captivate listeners. This track is a reminder of the power of curiosity and the importance of questioning the world around us.

17. “Roll To Me” – Del Amitri

© XS Noize

Del Amitri’s “Roll To Me” is a catchy, upbeat ode to love and companionship. Released in 1995, its lively melody and heartfelt lyrics celebrate the joy of being there for someone special. The song’s infectious rhythm and warm harmonies create a feel-good atmosphere. “Roll To Me” is a reminder of the happiness found in simple moments and connections. Its romantic charm and positive energy have made it a beloved track for those celebrating love and friendship. This hit continues to bring smiles to listeners, capturing the essence of joy and togetherness.

18. “Torn” – Natalie Imbruglia

© Grazia

Natalie Imbruglia’s “Torn” is a poignant exploration of heartbreak and self-discovery. Released in 1997, its emotive lyrics and melodic pop-rock sound capture the turmoil of romantic disillusionment. The song’s blend of vulnerability and strength creates a powerful emotional experience. “Torn” resonates with anyone who has faced the challenges of love and identity. Its raw honesty and compelling delivery have made it a timeless classic. This track continues to touch hearts with its exploration of the complexities of relationships and the journey to find oneself.

19. “Lullaby” – Shawn Mullins

© The Lyric Theatre

Shawn Mullins’ “Lullaby” is a soothing reflection on life’s ups and downs. Released in 1998, its gentle melody and narrative lyrics offer comfort and perspective. The song’s blend of folk and rock elements creates a calming atmosphere. “Lullaby” speaks to those seeking solace and understanding in a chaotic world. Its reassuring message and heartfelt delivery have made it a favorite for those in need of a musical embrace. This track continues to resonate with listeners who appreciate its comforting presence and introspective nature. It’s a reminder of the power of music to heal and soothe.

20. “Bittersweet Symphony” – The Verve

© Rolling Stone Australia

The Verve’s “Bittersweet Symphony” is a sweeping reflection on life and ambition. Released in 1997, its orchestral sound and introspective lyrics explore the tension between dreams and reality. The song’s blend of grandeur and melancholy creates a powerful listening experience. “Bittersweet Symphony” resonates with those pursuing their dreams amidst life’s challenges. Its majestic sound and poignant message have made it a timeless anthem. This track continues to inspire listeners to strive for their aspirations while acknowledging the bittersweet nature of life’s journey. It’s a reminder of the beauty and complexity of existence.