18 Forgotten Anniversary Customs That Deserve a Comeback

Culture & Society
By Jasmine Hughes

Modern anniversaries often revolve around dinner dates, social media posts, and maybe a gift card or bouquet. But once upon a time, couples celebrated love with traditions that were rich, meaningful, and sometimes delightfully quirky. Here are 18 anniversary customs from the past that totally deserve a comeback.

1. Handwritten Love Letters

© Etsy

Long before emojis and instant messages, there was the art of the handwritten love letter. Couples would spend hours crafting words full of emotion, every stroke of the pen an intimate expression of their feelings. Each letter became a keepsake, cherished and revisited over the years. In today’s digital age, these letters serve as a beautiful reminder of the power of words and the depth of personal connection. Imagine receiving a beautifully penned letter from your beloved, folded delicately, sealed with care. It’s a tradition that speaks of romance, thoughtfulness, and genuine affection.

2. Anniversary Scrapbooks

© Not on the High Street

Anniversary scrapbooks were once a popular way for couples to document their journey together. Each year, they would add photos, ticket stubs, and heartfelt notes, transforming it into a visual narrative of their shared experiences. These scrapbooks became time capsules, capturing the essence of each anniversary and the growth of their relationship. Today, in a time of fleeting digital memories, physical scrapbooks offer a tangible and enduring testament to love. This tradition invites creativity and collaboration, allowing couples to relive cherished moments each time they turn the page.

3. “Paper” First Anniversary Gifts

© Tidewater and Tulle

The tradition of giving paper gifts on the first anniversary symbolizes the beginning of a couple’s story. A simple handwritten note or a handcrafted book holds more sentimental value than any tech gadget. It’s a gesture that reflects thought and effort, highlighting the significance of personal touch. In the early years of marriage, this custom serves as a reminder of the sincerity and simplicity that love can embody. Reintroducing paper gifts can add warmth and depth to the celebration, encouraging couples to focus on meaningful gestures rather than material extravagance.

4. Recreating Your First Date

© Make a Date of It

Recreating the first date is a delightful way to relive the butterflies and excitement of the initial romantic encounter. Couples used to wear the same outfits, visit the same places, and even order the same meals to recreate the magic of that day. This nostalgic tradition invites couples to reflect on how far they’ve come while enjoying the simplicity and joy of their origins. It’s a playful nod to the early days of courtship, sparking laughter and fond memories. Such recreations are perfect for rekindling the love that brought them together.

5. Annual Vow Renewals at Home

© Dawn Photo

Vow renewals don’t need to be grand ceremonies. Many couples found meaning in simple vow renewals at home, under the twinkle of fairy lights or the glow of candles. This intimate tradition allowed them to reaffirm their promises in a setting that felt personal and sacred. Reading vows annually can be a poignant reminder of the commitment and love shared, reinforcing the emotional bond. It’s a practice that nurtures gratitude and reflection, offering couples a moment to pause and appreciate their journey together. This heartfelt custom truly honors the essence of marriage.

6. Exchanging Personal Keepsakes

© Amazon.com

Gift-giving doesn’t always require a hefty price tag. The tradition of exchanging personal keepsakes involved trading cherished items, like a favorite keychain or a sentimental bracelet. These keepsakes carried personal stories and memories, making them invaluable. Such exchanges were intimate gestures that spoke of trust and closeness. In a world dominated by materialism, this practice encourages couples to focus on sentimental value over monetary worth. Reintroducing this custom can enhance the emotional connection, reminding couples of the little things that hold their shared history.

7. Cooking the Wedding Meal

© The View at The Palm

Recreating the wedding meal at home is a flavorful way to walk down memory lane. Couples once embraced this tradition, cooking together the dishes that were served on their wedding day. It became a joyful culinary journey, filled with laughter, spills, and nostalgia. This experience allowed them to relive the tastes and aromas that marked the beginning of their married life. Sharing the meal became a celebration of how much they’ve grown and experienced together. By reviving this tradition, couples can savor the delicious memories of their love story.

8. Planting a Tree Together

© Oro Valley

Planting a tree together is a living symbol of commitment and growth. Couples once marked their anniversaries by adding to their garden, nurturing a tree that would grow alongside their relationship. This custom represented resilience, strength, and hope for the future. Each year, the tree stood taller, mirroring the couple’s journey and flourishing love. In today’s fast-paced world, this tradition offers a chance to connect with nature and each other. It’s a lasting reminder of the roots they’ve planted and the life they’ve cultivated together.

9. Anniversary Poems

© Etsy

Poetry has long been a favored medium for expressing deep emotions. Couples used to write anniversary poems, weaving words into verses that captured their feelings and shared experiences. Whether humorous or heartfelt, these poems were unique gifts that celebrated their love. Even a simple rhyme could bring laughter and tears, strengthening the emotional connection. In a time where text messages dominate, crafting a poem brings back the art of meaningful expression. This tradition invites creativity and vulnerability, allowing lovers to explore and articulate the depths of their affection.

10. Home Concerts

© Earth Below Photo

Home concerts were once an entertaining way for couples to celebrate their anniversaries. Whether singing a favorite song or playing an instrument, these performances were personal gifts filled with love and laughter. It didn’t matter if notes were missed or lyrics forgotten; the effort and sentiment were what made it special. In a cozy living room, surrounded by familiar sights and sounds, these concerts created memories that resonated deeply. This tradition offers a chance to embrace imperfections and share joy, bringing a harmonious note to the celebration of love.

11. Matching Outfits

© 4Lovebirds

Matching outfits might seem corny, but they were once a fun way for couples to express unity and togetherness. Coordinating clothing for an anniversary added a playful element to the celebration, showing the world their bond. It was a light-hearted way to share a laugh and embrace the whimsical side of love. This tradition invites creativity and humor, allowing couples to step outside the norm and enjoy a shared experience. In doing so, they celebrate their connection in a way that’s both visible and joyful.

12. Anniversary Picnics

© Bliss By The Sea

Anniversary picnics offered a serene escape from daily routines, allowing couples to reconnect in nature’s embrace. Packing a basket with homemade delicacies, they would retreat to a favorite spot, away from life’s noise. This simple yet meaningful tradition provided an intimate setting to share stories, laughter, and dreams. The tranquility of the outdoors enhanced the romantic experience, creating cherished memories. In today’s fast-paced world, revisiting this custom can offer a peaceful pause, where love is celebrated amidst the beauty of nature’s backdrop.

13. Gift-Giving Based on Yearly Themes

© Hallmark Ideas

Before the era of luxury brands and tech gadgets, couples followed traditional themes for anniversary gifts, like wood, silk, or tin. These themes invited creativity, as each year brought a new opportunity to find unique gifts that symbolized their relationship’s growth. Embracing this tradition encourages thoughtfulness and originality, as couples seek meaningful and symbolic gifts rather than expensive items. This practice enriches the celebration, adding layers of sentiment and intention. Reviving themed gift-giving can make each anniversary a delightful challenge filled with surprises and heartfelt gestures.

14. Midnight Toasts

© Toastmasters International

The ritual of a midnight toast marked the exact moment of their anniversary, creating a magical start to the day. Couples would stay up late, clinking glasses under the moonlight or cozying up by a fire. This intimate gesture was a celebration of time itself, honoring the past year and welcoming the next. It offered a quiet moment of reflection and anticipation, setting a romantic tone for the anniversary. In a world where time often rushes by, this tradition invites couples to pause and cherish every second together.

15. Creating a Time Capsule

© Paper Anniversary by Anna V.

Creating a time capsule was a cherished tradition for couples wanting to preserve moments in time. Each year, they would add mementos like notes, photos, or small trinkets, intending to open the capsule on a milestone anniversary. This practice allowed them to reflect on their journey, sparking nostalgia and appreciation for the years shared. It was a tangible way to capture the essence of their evolving relationship. In today’s transient world, revisiting this custom can offer a profound connection to the past and a hopeful glimpse into the future.

16. DIY Anniversary Cards

© Kenarry

DIY anniversary cards provided a canvas for creativity and personal expression. Couples would craft cards filled with inside jokes, colorful drawings, and heartfelt messages. Each card was a unique reflection of their love, offering charm that no store-bought card could match. This hands-on tradition allowed couples to share laughter and love, investing time and thought into every detail. In a world where convenience often trumps effort, handmade cards bring back the beauty of personal touch. They’re a testament to the care and attention that strengthens relationships.

17. Photographing Each Anniversary in the Same Spot

© Ecns.cn

A photo taken annually in the same location captures more than just physical change; it tells a story of growth and shared experiences. This tradition offers a visual narrative of love, where the backdrop remains constant while the couple evolves with each passing year. The collection of images becomes a cherished album, showcasing the passage of time and the milestones reached. In today’s digital age, this custom invites couples to step away from selfies and create a meaningful photographic journey that celebrates their enduring relationship.

18. Dancing in the Living Room

© Fine Art America

No fancy venue is needed for a dance in the living room. Couples used to sway to their favorite tunes in the comfort of their home, creating an atmosphere of intimacy and joy. This simple tradition allowed them to connect through music and movement, celebrating love without the need for extravagance. The living room became a stage, where laughter and romance took center stage. In today’s world, filled with distractions, this practice offers a moment of pure connection, where the focus is solely on each other and the rhythm of their hearts.