Back in Time Today
Disney’s live-action remakes have been a significant part of cinematic discussions, bringing beloved animated classics to life with new and varied interpretations.
While some films have soared in popularity and critical acclaim, others have stumbled, struggling to capture the magic of their animated predecessors.
This ranking explores all 22 live-action remakes, highlighting the nuances and narratives that either charmed or disenchanted audiences worldwide.
From technological advancements to storytelling shifts, each film offers a unique glimpse into Disney’s ambitious journey of reimagining its storied catalog.
22. Pinocchio (2022)
In Pinocchio (2022), the wooden puppet’s tale takes a darker turn with unsettling CGI that many found off-putting. The storytelling seemed to have lost the warmth and charm that characterized the original animated classic.
Set amidst a backdrop of a quaint Italian village, the film struggled to balance its modern retelling with the heartwarming simplicity of the original tale. Fans of the classic were left yearning for more emotional depth and less focus on visual splendor.
The film’s atmosphere, while visually intriguing, failed to captivate audiences on an emotional level.
21. Alice Through the Looking Glass (2016)
Alice Through the Looking Glass (2016) attempts to continue the fantastical journey but falters with its disjointed narrative. The sequel lacks the whimsy and coherence that made its predecessor a surreal escapade.
The film’s visual effects and vibrant settings, while captivating, couldn’t salvage the storyline that felt like a patchwork of fragmented tales.
Audiences were left bewildered rather than enchanted, as the narrative struggled to follow a clear path amidst the chaos of Wonderland. This film stands as a testament to the challenging task of creating a sequel that resonates with viewers.
20. Dumbo (2019)
Dumbo (2019), directed by Tim Burton, promised visual splendor but delivered an emotionally hollow experience. The small elephant with extraordinary ears flounders in a circus filled with larger-than-life characters.
Despite the breathtaking visuals and elaborate sets, the film struggled to evoke the emotional connection that made the animated original a timeless classic.
Burton’s signature style, with its dark and whimsical elements, couldn’t compensate for a narrative that lacked heart and depth. Viewers were left yearning for a connection that remained just out of reach, overshadowed by spectacle.
19. The Lion King (2019)
The Lion King (2019) dazzled with its groundbreaking CGI, bringing the African savanna and its inhabitants to life with stunning realism. However, this technological triumph came at a cost, losing the emotional expressiveness of its animated predecessor.
The animals, while visually breathtaking, lacked the emotive faces necessary to convey the depth of emotion central to the story’s heart.
Audiences were divided, admiring the film’s visual prowess yet longing for the warmth and expressiveness that defined the original. The remake stands as a testament to the delicate balance between visual innovation and storytelling depth.
18. Snow White (2025)
Snow White (2025), the latest adaptation, faced controversies and underperformed at the box office. Critiques were aimed at the film’s heavy reliance on CGI and its deviations from the cherished original tale.
Despite a visually enticing dark forest and a storyline with modern twists, the film struggled to resonate with audiences. The magic that once captivated hearts seemed diluted, leaving viewers longing for the simplicity and charm of the classic.
Controversies surrounding the casting and storyline added to the film’s challenges, overshadowing its visual achievements.
17. Maleficent: Mistress of Evil (2019)
Maleficent: Mistress of Evil (2019) expanded upon its predecessor’s tale but was seen as an unnecessary continuation. The film attempted to delve deeper into the complex relationship between Maleficent and Aurora.
Despite Angelina Jolie’s captivating presence, the sequel struggled to engage with its convoluted storyline and lack of fresh insight. Audiences felt the narrative was forced, lacking the surprise and freshness that marked the original.
This entry reiterates the challenges of extending a story that reached its natural conclusion, leaving audiences craving originality and emotional depth.
16. Aladdin (2019)
Aladdin (2019) brought the enchanting city of Agrabah to life with vibrant colors and catchy tunes. Will Smith’s portrayal of the genie added a fresh twist, yet fans felt the film lacked the magic of the animated version.
The bustling market scenes and dazzling palace interiors provided a feast for the eyes but couldn’t fully capture the original’s heartfelt essence. While the film entertained with its lively dance numbers and familiar story, the emotional punch seemed subdued.
The balance between nostalgia and innovation proved challenging, resulting in a visually appealing but emotionally restrained adaptation.
15. Lady and the Tramp (2019)
Lady and the Tramp (2019), released directly on Disney+, offered a charming retelling of the classic romance between a refined cocker spaniel and a street-smart mutt. While the film provided moments of nostalgia, it didn’t significantly stand out in Disney’s array of remakes.
The iconic spaghetti scene retained its charm, but the film’s small-screen debut limited its impact.
Though delightful, the remake struggled to achieve the grandeur expected from Disney’s theatrical endeavors. Nonetheless, it remains a sweet, albeit understated, addition to the live-action lineup.
14. Mulan (2020)
Mulan (2020) sought to honor Chinese culture and bring an epic tale of bravery to life with dazzling action sequences. However, it faced criticism for deviations from the beloved animated version.
The focus on realism and historical context offered a unique perspective but left some fans yearning for the musical magic. Despite its breathtaking landscapes and intense battle scenes, the film’s character development felt somewhat stunted.
While Mulan’s journey of self-discovery was compelling, the emotional depth seemed diluted, overshadowed by its epic scale and cinematic ambition.
13. 102 Dalmatians (2000)
102 Dalmatians (2000) aimed to capture the charm of its predecessor but fell short in the realm of storytelling. The film’s adventurous premise was overshadowed by a lackluster execution and predictable plotlines.
While the playful puppies provided moments of delight, the overall narrative couldn’t match the original’s engaging allure. Glenn Close returned as the iconic Cruella de Vil, adding a touch of flair, yet her presence wasn’t enough to elevate the film.
Fans of the original were left longing for the same wit and vibrancy that made 101 Dalmatians a beloved classic.
12. The Sorcerer’s Apprentice (2010)
The Sorcerer’s Apprentice (2010) ventured into modern-day magic with a mix of adventure and fantasy. Despite its entertaining premise, the film struggled to leave a lasting impression.
Nicholas Cage’s portrayal of a modern sorcerer added intrigue, yet the narrative lacked the depth and coherence needed to captivate audiences fully.
While the film offered moments of excitement and visual flair, its forgettable storyline couldn’t shine among Disney’s more iconic tales. The mix of modern settings and ancient magic provided an interesting backdrop but ultimately fell flat in execution.
11. Alice in Wonderland (2010)
Alice in Wonderland (2010) presented a visually inventive journey into a world of whimsy and wonder. Tim Burton’s signature style infused the film with eccentricity, though its convoluted plot left some viewers perplexed.
The vibrant landscapes and quirky characters provided a feast for the eyes but couldn’t entirely compensate for the narrative’s wandering nature. Despite its imaginative visuals, the film’s departure from the source material led to mixed reactions.
Fans appreciated the unique interpretation, yet the story’s lack of coherence left many yearning for more structured storytelling.
10. Maleficent (2014)
Maleficent (2014) offered a fresh perspective by retelling the story of Sleeping Beauty from the villain’s viewpoint. Angelina Jolie’s performance was a highlight, bringing depth and complexity to a character traditionally seen as evil.
The film’s exploration of love, betrayal, and redemption provided a captivating twist on a familiar tale. Audiences were drawn to the nuanced portrayal of Maleficent, finding empathy and understanding in her journey.
This reimagining breathed new life into the classic, offering a tale of transformation and the power of perspective.
9. Cruella (2021)
Cruella (2021) delivered a stylish origin story for one of Disney’s most iconic villains. Emma Stone’s performance was praised, capturing the rebellious spirit and creative genius of Cruella de Vil.
Set in the vibrant 1970s London fashion scene, the film brought a unique flair, blending punk rock aesthetics with high fashion drama. Audiences were intrigued by the backstory and transformation of Cruella, finding depth in her character that added layers to the villain they thought they knew.
The film’s bold style and engaging narrative made it a standout in Disney’s recent remakes.
8. Christopher Robin (2018)
Christopher Robin (2018) reimagines the beloved character as an adult, reconnecting with his childhood friends, Winnie the Pooh and the gang. The film offers a heartwarming tale of rediscovery and nostalgia.
Set amidst the picturesque English countryside, the story captures the essence of friendship and the importance of remembering one’s roots.
Audiences were touched by the gentle humor and tender moments, finding solace in the familiar warmth of Pooh’s world. This film reminds viewers of the joys of imagination and the enduring magic of childhood bonds.
7. 101 Dalmatians (1996)
101 Dalmatians (1996) brought the animated classic to life with a memorable performance by Glenn Close as Cruella de Vil. Her portrayal added a flamboyant flair, capturing the villain’s iconic style.
The film’s mix of live-action and charming canine antics brought joy to audiences, retaining the playful spirit of the original. The mischievous puppies and their daring escapades provided endless entertainment, while the lavish settings added a touch of elegance.
This adaptation remains a cherished reimagining, balancing humor, adventure, and a touch of villainous extravagance.
6. The Jungle Book (2016)
The Jungle Book (2016) seamlessly blended live-action and CGI, bringing Rudyard Kipling’s story to life with breathtaking visual effects.
The film’s engaging storytelling captured the essence of the jungle, making audiences feel like they were part of Mowgli’s adventure. The interactions between the young boy and his animal companions were both heartwarming and thrilling, showcasing the bond between man and nature.
This adaptation was praised for its visual innovation and faithful retelling, striking a balance that resonated with both fans of the original and new audiences alike.
5. Beauty and the Beast (2017)
Beauty and the Beast (2017) brought the enchanting tale to life with a strong cast and stunning musical numbers. Emma Watson’s portrayal of Belle captured the character’s intelligence and courage, resonating with audiences.
The film’s elaborate sets and visual effects created a magical atmosphere, enhancing the timeless story of love and transformation.
While staying faithful to the animated classic, the adaptation added new songs and depth, pleasing both fans and newcomers. The film’s balance of nostalgia and innovation made it a successful retelling of a beloved story.
4. Pete’s Dragon (2016)
Pete’s Dragon (2016) offered a heartfelt and refreshing take on the original, capturing the wonder of friendship between a boy and his magical dragon. The film’s focus on emotional connection resonated with audiences, bringing warmth to the story.
Set in a picturesque forest, the stunning visuals and touching narrative created a sense of enchantment. The film’s gentle storytelling and emphasis on love and loyalty made it a standout, offering a fresh perspective while honoring the spirit of the original.
Audiences found joy in its simplicity and the enduring magic of childhood imagination.
3. Cinderella (2015)
Cinderella (2015) delivered a faithful yet refreshing retelling of the classic fairy tale, with standout performances and stunning visuals. The film’s emphasis on kindness and courage resonated with audiences, capturing the timeless magic of the story.
The lavish sets and exquisite costumes created a fairy-tale atmosphere, enhancing the enchanting narrative. Lily James’s portrayal of Cinderella brought grace and warmth, while Cate Blanchett’s role as the stepmother added depth and intrigue.
This adaptation balanced tradition with innovation, delighting fans and newcomers alike with its elegance and heart.
2. The Little Mermaid (2023)
The Little Mermaid (2023) captured hearts with Halle Bailey’s enchanting performance and the film’s stunning musical sequences. Her portrayal of Ariel brought a fresh vibrancy, resonating with audiences who cherished the original.
The film’s underwater visuals and captivating songs created a magical world that delighted viewers, offering a sensory feast. Fans praised the balance between nostalgia and innovation, as the film retained the story’s essence while introducing new elements.
This adaptation succeeded in reviving the beloved tale, enchanting a new generation with its charm and creativity.
1. The Jungle Book (1994)
The Jungle Book (1994) may not have the technological advancements of later versions, but it was praised for its engaging storytelling and strong performances. The earlier adaptation brought a sense of adventure and wonder, capturing the spirit of the jungle.
The interactions between Mowgli and his animal friends were both heartwarming and adventurous, showcasing the timeless bond between man and nature.
This version remains a cherished retelling, emphasizing the story’s core themes and the enduring magic of Kipling’s world. Its simplicity and heartfelt narrative continue to resonate with fans.