Forget the Outlaws—The Real Firepower Belonged to These 14 Lawmen

General History
By Aria Moore

In the wild and lawless days of the American frontier, it wasn’t just the outlaws who wielded impressive firepower. The lawmen of this era were equipped with a formidable arsenal that helped them maintain order and justice.

From iconic revolvers to versatile rifles and even unconventional weapons like tomahawks, these tools were essential for survival and enforcement.

Here, we delve into the 14 weapons that armed the lawmen of the Wild West, each with its own story and significance.

1. Colt Single Action Army “Peacemaker”

© Morphy Auctions

The Colt Single Action Army, often called the “Peacemaker,” is perhaps the most iconic six-shooter of the Wild West. Used by legendary lawmen like Wyatt Earp and Pat Garrett, it was renowned for its reliability and power. Its simplicity and effectiveness made it a symbol of frontier justice. This revolver was instrumental in famous gunfights, offering precision and quick draw capabilities that made it a favorite among those who upheld the law in turbulent times. Its legacy continues, reflecting the rugged spirit of the American West.

2. Winchester Model 1873

© Rock Island Auction

Named “The Gun That Won the West,” the Winchester Model 1873 was a staple for any lawman on horseback. Its lever-action mechanism allowed for rapid fire, making it invaluable for pursuing outlaws. The rifle’s durability and range offered an edge in open terrain skirmishes. With its ability to deliver fast follow-up shots, it was indispensable for maintaining order across the vast plains. Lawmen appreciated its balance of power and accuracy, which helped in taming the wild frontier.

3. Smith & Wesson Schofield Revolver

© Bidsquare

The Smith & Wesson Schofield Revolver stood out with its top-break design, allowing for faster reloading than most contemporaries. Major George Schofield and the U.S. Cavalry favored this revolver for its innovative design. Its speed on reload and draw made it a cherished tool in high-stakes situations. This revolver was known for its durability and adaptability in various scenarios, from law enforcement to military operations. It exemplified the advancement in gun technology during its time.

4. Double-Barreled Shotgun

© Irongate Armory

Nothing could clear a saloon faster than a double-barreled shotgun, a favorite among lawmen like Virgil Earp. Known for its devastating power at close range, it was often sawed-off for better handling. This weapon was crucial in maintaining peace in rowdy environments. Its intimidating presence alone could diffuse a potentially violent situation. With its twin barrels, a lawman could deliver two shots in quick succession, ensuring immediate compliance or defense. It was a powerful tool in the lawman’s arsenal.

5. Remington Model 1875

© International Military Antiques

The Remington Model 1875 was a rugged and dependable alternative to the Colt revolvers of its time. Used by figures like Frank Canton, it offered similar power but with a distinct frame. This revolver was valued for its robustness and accuracy. Its design catered to the needs of lawmen who required reliable weaponry in unpredictable conditions. The Model 1875’s reputation for durability made it a trusted companion for those enforcing the law in often hostile territories, where performance could mean life or death.

6. Colt Lightning Rifle

© Reddit

The Colt Lightning Rifle, favored by the Texas Rangers, was known for its smooth pump-action operation. This rifle allowed for faster repeat shots compared to many lever-action guns of its time. Its speed and efficiency made it ideal for law enforcement duties requiring rapid response. The Lightning Rifle’s reputation for reliability and ease of use ensured it was a staple in the arsenal of those tasked with patrolling the expansive and often lawless Texan wilderness.

7. Derringer Pocket Pistol

© Cisco’s Gallery

With its compact size and simplicity, the Derringer Pocket Pistol was the choice for female law enforcers and undercover agents. It offered two shots without the need for a reload, making it a reliable backup weapon. Easily concealed in a boot or vest, it was crucial for close encounters where discretion was necessary. Though small, its presence was enough to alter the course of a confrontation. This pistol was a testament to the ingenuity needed for effective law enforcement in close-quarters.

8. Sharps 1874 Buffalo Rifle

© NRA Blog

The Sharps 1874 Buffalo Rifle was the sniper rifle of its era, renowned for its accuracy over long distances. Frontier scouts and sharpshooters favored it when precision was paramount. Capable of taking down a buffalo or an outlaw from over 1,000 yards, its power was unmatched. This rifle symbolized the strategic aspect of frontier law enforcement, where calculated shots often meant survival. Its legendary range and stopping power made it an indispensable tool for those protecting the frontier.

9. Colt 1851 Navy Revolver

© Flashbak

The Colt 1851 Navy Revolver, despite being eclipsed by newer models, remained a favorite of Wild Bill Hickok. Its balance and reliability were unmatched, and Hickok famously carried two of these ivory-handled revolvers. Known for their precision, they were a symbol of the calculated coolness required in high-stakes encounters. Hickok’s use of these revolvers in numerous duels and his eventual demise with them at his side cemented their place in Wild West lore, embodying the daring spirit of the lawman.

10. Pocket Colt 1849

© Rock Island Auction

In the unpredictable world of gambling and law enforcement, the Pocket Colt 1849 was a discreet ally. Often carried by gamblers turned lawmen, this small revolver offered a measure of defense in potentially hostile situations. Its compact size made it easy to conceal, ensuring it was close at hand when needed. Though less powerful than larger models, its presence could diffuse a situation or provide a quick draw advantage. This revolver represented the blurred lines between chance and justice in the Wild West.

11. Bowie Knife

© Rock Island Auction

The Bowie Knife was more than a weapon; it was a survival tool essential for the lawmen of the frontier. Used for everything from cutting rope to self-defense in close quarters, it was both intimidating and practical. The knife’s formidable size and sharp blade made it a symbol of toughness and self-reliance. Lawmen valued its multi-functional nature, often carrying it as a backup to their firearms. Its storied history and versatility made the Bowie Knife an iconic part of the lawman’s gear.

12. Springfield Trapdoor Rifle

© International Military Antiques

The Springfield Trapdoor Rifle, though slow to reload, was valued for its immense power. Carried by mounted lawmen and militias, it was crucial during sieges and long-range engagements. Its single-shot design emphasized precision and careful aim, reflecting the strategic approach needed in law enforcement. The rifle’s robust construction and formidable stopping power made it a trusted companion in tense situations. It represented the blend of patience and prowess required to maintain order in the challenging frontier environment.

13. Blackjack or Billy Club

© Museum of History & Industry

In the bustling towns of the Wild West, sometimes justice needed a silent approach. The blackjack or billy club was the perfect tool for urban sheriffs and marshals looking to subdue offenders without drawing too much attention. Its compact size and stealthy application made it ideal for dealing with drunkards or petty thieves. This tool allowed for the enforcement of law with discretion, avoiding the chaos of a shootout. Its effectiveness in maintaining order in urban settings made it indispensable.

14. Volcanic Pistol

© Kolser

The Volcanic Pistol, a precursor to the Winchester, was a rare but revolutionary lever-action firearm. Favored by innovative lawmen, it offered a repeating fire capability that was ahead of its time. While not widely adopted, those who wielded it appreciated its firepower in high-stakes scenarios. Its unique design and functionality represented the spirit of ingenuity and adaptation among frontier lawmen. The Volcanic Pistol was a glimpse into the future of firearms, embodying the progressive mindset required for survival and enforcement in the Wild West.