Back in Time Today
Some of the most iconic songs in music history were almost recorded by different artists. These songs, which have defined careers and set trends, could have had entirely different trajectories had they been given to the original intended artists. Here are 10 fascinating examples of iconic songs that were nearly given away, but ultimately found their true voice with another artist.
1. “Like a Prayer” – Madonna (1989)
Initially written with Janet Jackson in mind, “Like a Prayer” became a controversial anthem in Madonna’s hands. The song’s gospel-infused sound and provocative music video sparked debates worldwide. Imagine Janet’s silky voice over this track; it might have shaped her career differently. Ironically, the backlash from the infamous Pepsi ad controversy only added to its fame. Would Janet’s version have attracted the same media frenzy? We’ll never know, but Madonna’s adaptation turned the song into a cultural landmark, blending pop and religion in a way that only she could.
2. “I Will Always Love You” – Whitney Houston (1992)
Originally penned by Dolly Parton in 1973, this song almost became an Elvis Presley hit. Elvis wanted the track, but his manager demanded half the publishing rights, leading Dolly to decline. Whitney Houston later transformed it into a powerful ballad for “The Bodyguard” soundtrack. Her rendition became the best-selling single by a female artist. What if Elvis had recorded it? Would it have reached the same heights? Perhaps not. Whitney’s soulful performance brought new life to the song, turning it into an immortal classic.
3. “Toxic” – Britney Spears (2003)
“Toxic” was initially offered to Kylie Minogue, who passed on the track. Britney Spears’ release of the song became a defining moment in pop music. Her breathy, seductive vocals and the iconic music video, featuring her wrapped in nude fabric, captured audiences worldwide. Would Kylie’s version have achieved the same success? Britney’s unique style made “Toxic” unforgettable. The song’s edgy sound and daring visuals set a new standard in the early 2000s pop scene, solidifying Britney’s status as a pop icon.
4. “Smells Like Teen Spirit” – Nirvana (1991)
Before becoming the anthem of a generation, Kurt Cobain considered giving “Smells Like Teen Spirit” to Courtney Love’s band, Hole. The track’s raw energy and rebellious spirit defined the grunge movement. Had it been recorded by Hole, the song might have taken a different musical direction. Nirvana’s explosive performance introduced grunge to the mainstream, changing rock forever. Could Courtney’s band have captured the same essence? Regardless, Cobain’s decision to keep the song for Nirvana resulted in a cultural revolution.
5. “Hallelujah” – Leonard Cohen (1984)
Leonard Cohen’s “Hallelujah” was almost turned into a synth-pop remix. His label sought a commercial sound, but Cohen refused, keeping the song’s soulful depth intact. Jeff Buckley’s later cover brought the song widespread recognition. Imagine if it had gone disco; would it still be as revered? Cohen’s poetic lyrics and haunting melody have become a staple in music history. Today, “Hallelujah” is one of the most-covered songs ever, celebrated for its emotional resonance and timeless beauty, beyond any genre constraints.
6. “Umbrella” – Rihanna (2007)
Initially pitched to Britney Spears and Mary J. Blige, “Umbrella” became a massive hit for Rihanna. Spears passed on the track, and Blige’s team felt it wasn’t “urban enough.” Rihanna’s catchy “ella ella eh eh eh” hook became a global sensation. Would Britney or Mary have achieved the same impact? Rihanna’s distinct voice and style made the song inescapable. “Umbrella” marked a turning point in Rihanna’s career, showcasing her as a leading force in pop music and solidifying her place on the charts.
7. “All I Wanna Do” – Sheryl Crow (1994)
Written by a struggling poet, “All I Wanna Do” was nearly recorded by Stevie Nicks. Instead, Sheryl Crow transformed it into a breezy 90s anthem. The original demo was darker, but Crow injected a sunny vibe. Would Stevie have given it the same lightheartedness? The song became a defining hit for Crow, capturing the carefree spirit of the era. This track’s laid-back groove and whimsical lyrics resonated with audiences, making it a staple of 90s pop-rock radio.
8. “Man! I Feel Like a Woman!” – Shania Twain (1997)
“Man! I Feel Like a Woman!” started as a male country song by Shania’s producer/husband. Shania flipped the gender, creating a feminist anthem. Her energetic performance and the memorable music video, featuring her in a black top hat and coat, became iconic. Imagine if it had remained a male-driven track; would it have resonated the same way? Shania’s version celebrated female empowerment in a way that was both fun and bold. The song remains a beloved party anthem.
9. “Rolling in the Deep” – Adele (2011)
Co-writer Paul Epworth initially envisioned “Rolling in the Deep” for Leona Lewis, but Adele claimed it for herself. Her powerful vocals and emotive delivery turned it into a monumental hit. Would Leona’s version have matched its success? Adele’s passionate rendition captivated audiences, earning her a Grammy for Song of the Year. The song’s driving beat and soulful intensity resonated with listeners worldwide, marking a significant moment in Adele’s career and solidifying her status as a powerhouse vocalist.
10. “Bad Romance” – Lady Gaga (2009)
Before becoming Lady Gaga’s megahit, “Bad Romance” was almost given to Kesha or Katy Perry. Both artists passed on the track, allowing Gaga to make it her own. The song’s catchy “Rah rah ah-ah-ah!” hook and avant-garde music video became instant pop culture phenomena. Would Kesha or Katy have pushed the boundaries as Gaga did? Her unique blend of theatricality and pop innovation redefined the genre, making “Bad Romance” an unforgettable part of music history.