Back in Time Today
Reese’s is a candy aisle legend, with its iconic peanut butter and chocolate combo dominating lunchboxes, movie theaters, and holiday baskets for decades. But beyond the classic cups, Reese’s has dabbled in all kinds of flavors and formats—some unforgettable, others gone too soon.
Here’s a list of 15 Reese’s flavors, both old and new, that left a lasting impression.
1. Classic Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
Ah, the classic Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup! With its smooth milk chocolate exterior cradling a creamy peanut butter heart, this treat has been a staple for candy lovers for decades. Each bite offers a perfectly balanced taste of sweet and salty, delighting the taste buds.
Nostalgia wraps around you with every unwrapping, transporting you back to childhood memories of Halloween hauls and lunchtime treats. Despite the many innovative flavors Reese’s has introduced, nothing quite compares to the original. Whether you’re enjoying them at a movie theater or sneaking one from a friend’s stash, they never disappoint.
2. Reese’s Big Cup
For those who believe more is more, the Reese’s Big Cup is your kind of candy. Taking the beloved classic and amplifying it, these oversized cups pack in more peanut butter goodness than ever before.
The extra thickness gives you a mouthful of creamy peanut butter, enveloped in rich chocolate, offering a blissful experience that’s truly satisfying. Perfect for sharing or savoring solo, the Big Cup is a favorite among serious peanut butter enthusiasts. It’s a testament to the idea that sometimes, bigger really is better.
3. Reese’s Pieces
Remember the candy-coated gems that first burst onto the scene in the 1980s? Reese’s Pieces quickly became a fan favorite, thanks to their crunchy exterior and soft peanut butter center. Perfect for on-the-go snacking, these bite-sized delights are a playful twist on the traditional cup.
Their colorful shell makes them eye-catching, and their distinct lack of chocolate sets them apart. Whether you’re filling up a candy bowl or adding them to your movie night treats, Reese’s Pieces are a must-have for peanut butter lovers craving something a little different.
4. Reese’s PB&J Cups
The beloved childhood sandwich meets candy innovation with Reese’s PB&J Cups. This delightful twist features a mix of creamy peanut butter and luscious jelly, all encased in classic chocolate.
Available in grape or strawberry, each bite is a nostalgic nod to simpler times, evoking memories of packed school lunches. New to the scene, these cups have already created a buzz among fans eager to try a sweet, jelly-filled surprise. It’s the perfect hybrid of two beloved treats, bringing a playful twist to the Reese’s family.
5. Reese’s Red Velvet Cups
Celebrating love and indulgence, Reese’s Red Velvet Cups bring a romantic twist to the traditional flavor. The combination of rich red velvet creme with creamy peanut butter creates a decadent treat sure to woo chocolate lovers.
Perfect for Valentine’s Day, these festive cups bring a pop of color to any candy dish. The beautiful pairing of sweet and savory will have you swooning, making it a delightful gift for loved ones or a charming treat for yourself. Each bite truly is a taste of love.
6. Reese’s Carrots
Who says veggies can’t be fun? Reese’s Carrots are here to delight both young and old with their playful carrot shape and deliciously familiar taste. Wrapped in festive Easter packaging, these treats make for a perfect basket stuffer.
Beneath the whimsical appearance lies the timeless combination of peanut butter and chocolate that Reese’s fans adore. Offering both visual appeal and yummy goodness, Reese’s Carrots are a springtime favorite that add a touch of whimsy to holiday celebrations.
7. Reese’s White Chocolate Cups
For those with a penchant for white chocolate, Reese’s White Chocolate Cups present a creamy alternative to the classic milk chocolate. The smooth white chocolate complements the salty peanut butter, creating a sweet contrast that tempts the taste buds.
While some purists may shy away, fans of this version relish the unique twist on a beloved favorite. Perfect for those seeking a subtly different flavor adventure, these cups remain a popular choice in the ever-expanding Reese’s lineup.
8. Reese’s Dark Chocolate Cups
For those who crave a richer, more intense chocolate experience, Reese’s Dark Chocolate Cups are a dream come true. The deep, dark chocolate enhances the creamy peanut butter filling, offering a more grown-up twist on the classic.
This version appeals to those who appreciate a less sweet, more robust flavor profile. Perfect with a cup of coffee or a glass of red wine, these cups provide a sophisticated treat for any time of day.
9. Reese’s Swoops
Fond memories of Reese’s Swoops linger among candy enthusiasts. These thin, curved chocolate slices mimicked the shape of potato chips, providing a unique way to enjoy Reese’s flavor.
Though discontinued, their innovative concept and delightful taste left a lasting impression on those lucky enough to indulge. Perfectly portioned for snacking, Reese’s Swoops were a playful addition to the candy aisle, offering a fun twist on traditional chocolate bars.
10. Reese’s Whipps
Reese’s Whipps brought a lighter texture to the candy bar scene with their nougat-centered delight. Unlike denser bars, Whipps offered a fluffy, airy experience, all while maintaining a subtle peanut butter profile.
Fans fondly recall the unique texture and satisfying bite that set it apart from typical candy bars. Although it’s no longer available, Reese’s Whipps remains a cherished memory for those who enjoyed its lightness paired with signature Reese’s flavors.
11. Reese’s Bites
Once a go-to snack for many, Reese’s Bites offered convenience and taste in one small package. These bite-sized morsels were perfect for popping on the go, making them a hit with busy snackers.
However, their run was cut short due to safety concerns, leaving a void in the hearts of fans who appreciated their poppable nature. Fondly remembered, Reese’s Bites remain a nostalgic favorite, cherished for their ease and delightful flavor.
12. Reese’s Peanut Butter & Banana Creme Cups
Inspired by the King’s favorite sandwich, Reese’s Peanut Butter & Banana Creme Cups melded creamy peanut butter with a layer of banana creme. This limited edition offering captured the hearts of those adventurous enough to try it, evoking the legendary combination adored by Elvis Presley.
Though no longer available, its unique flavor remains unforgettable, sparking curiosity and craving among fans of novelty treats. These cups were a short-lived, yet much-loved nod to a classic sandwich.
13. Reese’s Crunchy Cookie Cup
For those who crave texture, Reese’s Crunchy Cookie Cup delivers an exciting twist. This variant combines the classic peanut butter filling with bits of crunchy cookie, offering a delightful crunch in every bite.
A favorite among texture lovers, these cups provide a satisfying contrast to the smoothness of the chocolate and peanut butter. While not always easily found, their occasional appearances in stores are greeted with enthusiasm by fans.
14. Reese’s Stuffed with Pretzels or Potato Chips
Reese’s has a talent for mixing sweet and salty, and their stuffed cups with pretzels or potato chips are no exception. These limited editions offer a surprising crunch and a salty twist that enhances the classic flavor.
The combination of salty snacks with the peanut butter and chocolate makes for a satisfyingly addictive treat. Keep an eye out for these seasonal favorites, as they offer a delightful surprise for those who enjoy adventurous flavors.
15. Reese’s Tab with Chocolate or Peanut Butter Lovers Cups
Reese’s has taken sides in the eternal chocolate vs. peanut butter debate with their Tab Cups. Some boast an extra layer of chocolate, while others amp up the peanut butter filling.
This playful take allows fans to choose their allegiance, offering a tailored taste experience. Whether you’re a devoted chocolate lover or a peanut butter enthusiast, these cups cater to your preference, making them a fun addition to any Reese’s lineup.