20 Most Hated Songs from the ’70s That Everyone Secretly Loves

Pop Culture
By Ella Brown

The 1970s, a decade of musical exploration, gifted us with tracks that, despite divided opinions, hold a special place in our hearts. While some songs were widely celebrated, others faced critique and disdain.

Yet, beneath the surface of controversy, these melodies have woven themselves into the fabric of nostalgia. Here, we take a closer look at 20 tracks that might not have topped critics’ lists but continue to resonate with hidden admiration.

Whether it’s the quirky lyrics or the catchy beats, these songs have a charm that’s hard to resist.

1. “Muskrat Love” by Captain & Tennille

© Amazon.com

“Muskrat Love,” a soft rock tune by Captain & Tennille, was a peculiar hit in the ‘70s. The whimsical lyrics about muskrats in love drew both fascination and ridicule. Despite its odd theme, the melody remains catchy.

Listeners often find themselves humming along, enchanted by its quirky charm. The song’s unique narrative stands out, making it a memorable piece from the era.

Even if laughed at, it’s secretly cherished for its bold storytelling. It’s a reminder of the decade’s experimental spirit, blending humor and melody in unexpected ways.

2. “Afternoon Delight” by Starland Vocal Band

© Amazon.com

“Afternoon Delight” by the Starland Vocal Band is a song that evokes immediate reactions. Known for its suggestive lyrics paired with cheerful harmonies, it became an unexpected hit.

Despite the initial embarrassment it might cause, many appreciate its catchy tune and daring theme. The song’s lighthearted nature appeals to those who enjoy a playful take on romance.

Secretly, it’s a guilty pleasure for many, representing the carefree, adventurous spirit of the ‘70s. Its unique blend of innocence and innuendo keeps it alive in listeners’ playlists.

3. “Billy, Don’t Be a Hero” by Paper Lace

© Apple Music

“Billy, Don’t Be a Hero” became a prominent song in the ‘70s, though often criticized for its melodrama. The narrative about a soldier in love struck a chord with many.

Despite its theatrical style, it has an undeniable emotional pull. The chorus, in particular, resonates with listeners who embrace its storytelling.

Even if seen as overly dramatic, it remains endearing due to its heartfelt message. It’s a reminder of the era’s penchant for narrative-driven songs, capturing emotions with earnest simplicity.

4. “Disco Duck” by Rick Dees

© Rate Your Music

“Disco Duck,” performed by Rick Dees, is a novelty hit that defined the unique flair of the ‘70s disco era. The song, featuring duck-like vocals, delivered infectious energy.

Despite being mocked for its silliness, it became a dance floor favorite. Its playful beat and quirky concept make it a memorable tune.

Listeners often find themselves tapping along, embracing its whimsical nature. It captures the spirit of fun that defined disco, making it a beloved, albeit amusing, classic in many collections.

5. “Seasons in the Sun” by Terry Jacks

© Amazon.com

“Seasons in the Sun” by Terry Jacks, although often perceived as overly sentimental, is a track that tugs at the heartstrings. Its melancholic lyrics paired with a soothing melody leave a lasting impact.

Listeners connect with its themes of farewell and reflection, finding solace in its gentle tones. Despite criticisms for being too somber, it’s a song many hold dear.

It embodies the bittersweet essence of farewells, resonating with those who appreciate its emotional depth. Its legacy lies in its ability to evoke nostalgia and contemplation.

6. “Feelings” by Morris Albert

© Amazon.com

“Feelings” by Morris Albert is often remembered for its earnest, heartfelt expression. Though critiqued for its repetitive lyrics, the song’s emotional delivery remains powerful.

Listeners are drawn to its sincerity, making it a favorite for those who appreciate raw emotion. The simplicity of its melody complements the depth of feeling it conveys.

Despite being labeled as clichéd, it’s a piece that continues to touch hearts. Its universal theme of longing and loss ensures its place in the playlists of those who value emotional connections.

7. “You Light Up My Life” by Debby Boone

© Amazon.com

“You Light Up My Life” by Debby Boone captured the essence of heartfelt devotion. Criticized for its saccharine sweetness, it nonetheless became an anthem of love.

Listeners are captivated by its strong, emotional vocals and tender lyrics. The song’s simplicity enhances its sincerity, allowing it to resonate deeply.

Often dismissed for being overly sentimental, it nonetheless finds a place in many hearts. Its enduring appeal lies in its ability to connect with those seeking genuine expressions of love and hope.

8. “Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Ole Oak Tree” by Tony Orlando and Dawn

© Amazon.com

“Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Ole Oak Tree” by Tony Orlando and Dawn tells a story of hope and redemption. The song, though seen as overly sentimental, is treasured for its narrative.

Listeners are drawn into its tale of longing and forgiveness, embracing its catchy melody. Its repetitive chorus adds to its charm, making it a significant piece of the ‘70s.

Even if viewed as simplistic, it holds a special place for its message of love and second chances. It continues to inspire those who believe in the power of reconciliation.

9. “Y.M.C.A.” by Village People

© Deezer

“Y.M.C.A.” by the Village People is a disco classic known for its infectious dance moves and upbeat tempo. Despite its commercial nature, it quickly became a cultural phenomenon.

Listeners are drawn to its vibrant energy and inclusive message, making it a staple at parties. The song’s catchy chorus and danceable beat are hard to resist.

Even if initially dismissed as a novelty, it leaves a lasting impression with its celebration of community and fun. It’s a testament to the power of music to bring people together.

10. “My Ding-a-Ling” by Chuck Berry

© Stereogum

“My Ding-a-Ling” by Chuck Berry is a humorous tune that sparked mixed reactions. Known for its playful lyrics, it became Berry’s only number-one hit.

The song’s cheeky nature often led to controversy, yet it entertained audiences with its lighthearted approach. Listeners appreciate its humor, finding joy in its catchy refrain.

Despite the debates it stirred, it remains a fun, memorable piece from the era. Its ability to entertain and amuse ensures its place in the hearts of those who enjoy a good laugh with their music.

11. “Escape (The Piña Colada Song)” by Rupert Holmes

© Amazon.com

“Escape (The Piña Colada Song)” by Rupert Holmes is a narrative-driven tune that drew mixed reviews. The song’s storyline about rekindling love through unexpected means intrigued listeners.

Despite its initial reception, it became a favorite for its catchy melody and relatable theme. The twist in its lyrics adds a layer of surprise that many appreciate.

Even if considered trivial by some, it embodies the carefree essence of the ‘70s. Its enduring popularity rests on its playful take on relationships and adventure.

12. “Kung Fu Fighting” by Carl Douglas

© Deezer

“Kung Fu Fighting” by Carl Douglas is a song synonymous with the disco era’s lively spirit. Criticized for its novelty, it nevertheless became an international hit.

Listeners are captivated by its energetic beat and engaging lyrics. The song’s martial arts theme adds a unique twist, making it a standout track.

Despite being viewed as gimmicky, it continues to delight with its infectious rhythm. It captures the excitement of the disco scene, ensuring its place as a beloved classic for those who enjoy a bit of fun with their music.

13. “Don’t Give Up on Us” by David Soul

© Apple Music

“Don’t Give Up on Us” by David Soul, although often dubbed as overly sentimental, is a ballad that resonates with many. Its theme of perseverance in love appeals to listeners.

The song’s soothing melody coupled with emotive lyrics provides comfort and hope to those who cherish romantic ideals. Even if criticized for its simplicity, it holds a place in the hearts of those who believe in enduring love.

It’s a reminder of the ‘70s focus on heartfelt ballads, celebrating the strength of emotional connections.

14. “Convoy” by C. W. McCall

© BrooklynVegan

“Convoy” by C. W. McCall, a novelty song about truckers, became an unexpected hit despite its niche theme. The catchy CB radio lingo and vivid storytelling resonated with audiences.

Listeners are drawn into its adventurous narrative, celebrating the camaraderie of the open road. Even if seen as gimmicky, it captures the independent spirit of the ‘70s.

Its charm lies in its unique subject matter, providing a glimpse into a subculture that fascinated the nation. It remains a delightful piece for those who appreciate storytelling through music.

15. “Rock Me Gently” by Andy Kim

© eBay

“Rock Me Gently” by Andy Kim is a soft rock tune that embodies the smooth sounds of the ‘70s. While sometimes overlooked, its gentle melody and warm vocals are captivating.

Listeners appreciate its soothing qualities and romantic undertones, making it a favorite for those who enjoy mellow tracks. The song’s simplicity adds to its charm, allowing its heartfelt message to shine.

Despite its subtle presence, it holds an enduring appeal for those who treasure its calming effect. It’s a testament to the understated beauty of soft rock from that era.

16. “I’ve Never Been to Me” by Charlene

© Apple Music

“I’ve Never Been to Me” by Charlene, though often dismissed for its introspective lyrics, tells a poignant story of self-discovery. Its reflective tone connects with those seeking meaning in life.

Listeners find resonance in its narrative, appreciating the vulnerability and honesty it conveys. The song’s emotional depth offers comfort to those on similar journeys.

Despite initial skepticism, it remains a cherished piece for its sincere exploration of personal growth. Its legacy is built on its ability to touch hearts, inviting introspection and empathy.

17. “Mandy” by Barry Manilow

© Stereogum

“Mandy” by Barry Manilow is a ballad that strikes a deep chord with its passionate delivery. Criticized for its sentimentality, it nonetheless won hearts with its powerful emotion.

Listeners are moved by its heartfelt lyrics, finding solace in its depiction of longing and love. The song’s orchestration adds to its dramatic effect, creating an immersive experience.

Despite its dramatic flair, it holds a special place for those who appreciate its sincerity. It’s a reminder of the timeless appeal of love ballads that speak to the soul.

18. “Play That Funky Music” by Wild Cherry

© Music | MisterG – Bandcamp

“Play That Funky Music” by Wild Cherry is a quintessential ‘70s funk anthem known for its groovy beat and spirited lyrics. Initially underestimated, it became a dance floor staple.

Listeners are drawn to its infectious rhythm and vibrant energy, making it impossible to sit still. The song’s call to embrace the funk resonates with fans of the genre.

Despite its initial reception, it endures as a lively testament to the era’s musical creativity. It’s a celebration of dance and joy that continues to inspire movement and happiness.

19. “The Night Chicago Died” by Paper Lace

© Deezer

“The Night Chicago Died” by Paper Lace, although criticized for its historical inaccuracies, is a song with a captivating narrative. Its storytelling captures the listener’s imagination.

Despite its embellishments, the song’s catchy chorus and dramatic flair leave a lasting impression. Listeners are intrigued by its vivid imagery and engaging plot.

Even if factually flawed, it remains a beloved piece for its entertainment value. It highlights the ‘70s love for narrative-driven songs that transport listeners to different worlds through music.

20. “Love Will Keep Us Together” by Captain & Tennille

© Amazon.com

“Love Will Keep Us Together” by Captain & Tennille is a jubilant anthem that celebrates enduring love. Although seen as overly positive, it won the hearts of many with its catchy tune.

Listeners appreciate its upbeat message and harmonious vocals, making it a favorite for romantics. The song’s cheerful tempo adds to its irresistible charm.

Despite its simplistic theme, it holds an enduring appeal for those who believe in lasting relationships. It’s a joyful reminder of love’s power to unite and uplift, resonating with listeners across generations.